MAKE THE CALL: The Patriots Have A Better Shot At A Playoff Run With Jimmy G Than They Do With Tommy Cutlets
Yep, I said it.
And I stand by it.
It sure sounds like Drake Maye is going to be out for the season with an ankle injury. It sucks we don't get to watch Maye play the rest of the season. But there are still seven games to be played. And to me, it's clear that Jimmy Garoppolo would give the Patriots a better chance to win four of their final seven games and claim the #7 seed in the AFC Playoffs.
Giphy Images.
Ezra Shaw. Getty Images.
Tim Bradbury. Getty Images.Yes, the former Patriot Jimmy Garoppolo, who last threw an official NFL pass on January 5, 2025. He played for the Rams all of last season, but got in for just nine plays behind MVP Matt Stafford, taking nine QB kneel-downs for -10 rushing yards. What a season!
We're not that far removed from the 2022 season, with Jimmy G going 7-3 for the 49ers, throwing 16 TDs to just 4 INTs in relief of the injured Trey Lance. He got hurt late that season, and the 49ers would lose to the Eagles in the NFC Championship Game.

Advertisement
From there, it was off to a blah year with Josh McDaniels and the Raiders and then a few years with the Rams, backing up Stafford. I find it noteworthy that three of the best offensive minds of this era - Kyle Shanahan, Sean McVay, and McDaniels - all chose to employ him over the last few seasons.
Kathryn Riley. Getty Images.Now, the guy likely to try to lead the Patriots to four wins over their last seven games is Tommy DeVito.
Giphy Images.Tommy Cutlets is a great story, but if you watched him at all on Sunday over in Germany, you know he's not the guy.

Advertisement
He was bad against a mediocre Lions D. Nice story, fellow Italian, not a great quarterback.

I mean, look at these teams fighting for the last AFC Playoff spot. This is the whole point -if the Pats get to nine wins, they're going to get in as the seven-seed. At worst, you're looking at a tiebreaker - and the Pats are 5-1 in the AFC 👀👀👀
Jimmy G is a better player, has a history with Josh McDaniels, and has played in some big games. Selfishly, it would also be a very cool story to see him come back and guide the Pats to the playoffs.
His last actual game was the Rams' season finale in early 2025. He went 27-for-41 for 334 yards and 2 TDs with Jordan Whittington, DeMarcus Robinson, and Tutu Atwell out there. The guy can still sling it. For the record, DeVito has never thrown for 300+ yards in a game.
If you're a Pats fan, it comes down to what you're looking for over these final seven games after the bye. Me? I would like the Pats to compete down the stretch - especially with two island games in primetime. I'd like to see some fight for Mike Vrabel and some evidence that last season wasn't a massive schedule fluke. Getting back to the playoffs with no Drake Maye would also show some balls…some toughness. But you need four wins.
There are three wins there for the taking: Chargers, Jets, and Bills. That gets you to eight. Can you win one of four against the Bills, Chiefs, Vikings, or Broncos?
With Tommy Cutlets, no.
With Jimmy G? There's one win there. He's just a much better player and has had a much better career.

Advertisement
And he's also a gentleman! Gentleman Jim! Print the T-shirts!
My podcast buddy Hogdale thinks it's over. He wants the tank. Jerry was too rattled to talk tank - he's with me on the Jimmy G story. If you want the tank, then you hate the idea and should be hoping it's DeVito, or rookie Berhen Morton, who I guess is a real person.
I want to compete. If that's gonna happen, the team needs to go sign a quarterback this week.
And I hope it's Jimmy G.